Skip to main content
Predictably Irrational
Chapter 2 · 3.5 min · 2 of 13

The Fallacy of Supply and Demand

A chapter summary from Predictably Irrational by Dan Ariely.

Affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Read Stacks earns from qualifying purchases and Audible memberships at no extra cost to you. Audible shows its current offer and terms before you join.

Participants whose SSNs ended in higher numbers consistently bid higher for the same items. The number was random, but once it was in mind it served as an anchor that shaped subsequent valuations.

The argument generalizes to consumer behavior. The price of any new product category — when smartphones first appeared, when bottled water first appeared, when streaming subscriptions first appeared — is anchored by whatever the first widely-publicized price was. Subsequent prices for similar products cluster around the anchor regardless of whether the anchor reflects any underlying value. Markets do clear, but they clear at price levels that are partly arbitrary historical accidents.

The chapter's deeper implication is uncomfortable for economic theory: if prices are partly arbitrary, then the welfare-maximizing claims of free markets are weaker than the standard story suggests. The practical implication for individuals is to recognize that the price tag on most products has only a loose connection to what the product is actually worth, and to evaluate purchases against personal value rather than against the prevailing market anchor.

Participants who happened to have high two-digit endings to their Social Security numbers bid 60-120% more for the same wine, gadgets, and chocolate than those with low endings — proof that a demonstrably random number, once written down, anchored every subsequent valuation. Ariely names the result arbitrary coherence: the first price is arbitrary, but once accepted it coherently orders all later prices, so the relationships between prices feel sensible even though the starting point was noise. He extends it to the market with Starbucks, which deliberately built an unfamiliar environment and vocabulary so customers would not anchor on Dunkin's coffee prices and would instead accept a new, higher anchor. We also self-herd, anchoring on our own past purchases and repeating them as if they proved value. The chapter's unsettling conclusion is that demand curves are partly manufactured by the anchors sellers set, so 'willingness to pay' often measures an accepted anchor rather than any underlying worth.

What the chapter means, in one line: the first price you accept for something is often an accident, but every price after it gets judged against that accident. Ariely calls this arbitrary coherence. The starting point is arbitrary; what follows is consistent with it, which is why the whole thing feels rational from the inside.

Where it comes from. The auction with the last two digits of a Social Security number was run with MIT business students and published by Ariely, George Loewenstein and Drazen Prelec as "Coherent Arbitrariness" (Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2003). The same paper ran the test in the other direction, with unpleasant sounds: people named a price to sit through a noise, and the first figure suggested to them shaped every later answer, even though they had just heard exactly how bad the noise was. The chapter's Tom Sawyer example makes the same point with something you cannot price in advance. Offer a poetry reading as an event people pay for and they ask how much; offer it as something they will be paid to sit through and they ask for money. Nothing about the poetry changed. The frame told people which side of zero it belonged on.

How to use it. Before you see a price, write down what the thing is worth to you, in money or in hours of work. Treat a list price, a "was" price or a first offer in a negotiation as an anchor, not as information about value. When you notice you always buy the same coffee, the same brand or the same subscription tier, ask whether you are repeating a decision or only repeating the first price you said yes to; that habit is what Ariely calls self-herding. And if you set prices yourself, the chapter explains why the first number you publish matters more than any later discount.

The limits. The Social Security result is the most quoted part of the chapter, and later work found it smaller. Maniadis, Tufano and List repeated the design (American Economic Review, 2014) and found anchoring effects far weaker than the original. Anchoring itself is one of the most replicated findings in behavioural research; what is in doubt is how strong a meaningless anchor is when people are paying real money for things they know. So the safe reading is: anchors move prices, plausible anchors move them most, and the random-number version is the dramatic case rather than the typical one. The chapter before this one, the truth about relativity, covers the related habit of judging a price only against the options next to it, and chapter 3 on the cost of zero cost shows what happens when the anchor is free.

Up next · Chapter 3 · 1.5 min
The Cost of Zero Cost
Continue reading
Share as card →

More from Predictably Irrational

If this resonated, read across the stack

Predictably Irrational sits in a curated reading path — each pairing it with other books that sharpen the same idea. Three nearest peers:

Full paths:Think clearly

Questions about this chapter

What is Chapter 2 of Predictably Irrational about?+

Standard economics assumes that prices reflect the underlying value of goods, determined by supply and demand in a market. Ariely's chapter argues that price is far more arbitrary than this picture suggests. Prices are anchored — set by reference points that often have nothing to do with the underlying value of the product.

What's the key takeaway from Chapter 2 of Predictably Irrational?+

The chapter's lab experiment had participants write down the last two digits of their social security numbers, then bid on various items in an auction.

How long does the Predictably Irrational Chapter 2 summary take to read?+

About 4 minutes — the core insight from Predictably Irrational by Dan Ariely, free on Read Stacks.

From Read Stacks · Learn

If you just read a chapter summary…

You're using the navigation tool the way it was designed to be used. Two short essays on the meta-skill — what summaries actually preserve, and the six retention techniques that decide whether what you just read is still useful six months from now.

Did you find what you were looking for?